The Best Cat Litter for Multiple Cats

The Best Cat Litter for Multiple Cats

Cats, unlike dogs, are not pack animals. Even kitty siblings, from the same litter, tend to want their own space. Sharing a litter box can be stressful for some cats. A multi-cat household should have the same number of litter boxes as the number of cats, plus an extra box. Your cats probably have very different personalities and this means they may also have different quirks about using the litter box. One may be an active digger who conjures up dust in the air or leaves more litter outside of the box than inside. Some cats may prefer one type of litter while others want another type. This is not unusual in households that have an older cat and a younger cat.  Sometimes the older cat may need to use a specialized litter that is designed to be gentler on their paws while the younger doesn’t need this requirement.  Some cats maybe more sensitive to litter dust or perfumes which require them to use a more natural cat litter. While all this may seem overwhelming, you know your cats best. But before you make a final decision on a cat litter for your multiple cats please read on.

Types of Cat Litter

Clumping Clay – This is one of the most popular types of kitty litter. Most clumping clay litters are made from bentonite, which is a highly absorbent clay that forms clumps when exposed to liquids. The benefit of a clumping clay is that cleaning the litter box is easy. Both scented and unscented varieties are available in clumping clay litter.

Non-Clumping Clay – This type of clay litter still absorbs moisture, but does not form clumps. This could result in cleaning your cat’s litter box more often. Non-clumping clay litter tends to be cheaper than its clumping counterpart.

Crystal – Crystal litter is typically made of small bits of dried silica. It tends to be more expensive than other types of cat litter. Fans of crystal litter say it’s worth the price tag because it lasts longer, dust-free and is biodegradable.

Pine – This is a natural, recycled option. Pine litter needs to be replaced more often than some of the more traditional options, but the fresh scent has made believers out of many cat owners.

Paper – This type of cat litter is made from post-consumer recycled paper and is available in pellet or granule form. Paper litter contains no dust and is absorbent. Regular litter box cleaning will be necessary with the pellet form because clumping does not happen. You can expect clumps with the granule variety.


What to Consider When Choosing a Cat Litter for Multiple Cats

High Absorbency – Litters made for multiple cats typically are more absorbent than those marketed for general use. This means it will soak up more fluids, clump better and create a more efficient litter box.

Low Dust and Minimal Tracking – Look for a litter that doesn’t create a cloud of dust every time you pour it into litter box. High-dust litters can cause respiratory problems and can contribute to litter tracking.

Clumping – Considered the best for all types of cat litter and situations. When it comes to cat litter, clumping is everything. If a litter does not clump well, the litter box and the area around it will be a mess. Weak clumping ability means you will have a hard time cleaning your litter box and will use more litter over time.

Extreme Odor Control – These litters are better at controlling odors which is important in a multiple cat home. The right litter can help to neutralize odors through effective absorption and the right materials. Litters that contain chemical fragrances are rarely preferred by cats. While they may smell good to some humans, they’re offensive to your cat’s sense of smell. A good unscented litter is the best choice.

Top 5 Best Cat Litter for Multiple Cats

Worlds Best Cat Litter

The Best Cat Litter for Multiple CatsWorld’s Best is different from other litters because its made out of natural, non-toxic, ground corn husks. New users are usually shocked by how light weight it is and while the aroma (of corn) is unique, it isn’t over-powering and is easy to adapt to. Some cats, and other animals if you have them, have been caught eating this litter. World’s Best can be a bit more costly than other brands among flushable litters. Consistent users claim the price is worth it because this product lasts longer than other litters, so that very little goes to waste. World’s Best also has superb clumping abilities. Also, the corn is excellent at absorbing moisture which reduces the amount of bacteria, the main cause of litter box odor, left behind.

The Good

  • Clumps solid
  • Flush-able
  • Lasting odor control

The Bad

  • Some complain of ammonia smell
  • Some dust

sWheat Scoop Multi  Cat Litter 

The sWheat Scoop Multi Cat Natural Litter  eliminate odors, clump faster, and outlast other litters. It does not contain chemicals, silica dust, or sodium bentonite (clay). It is unique in that it is farmer-owned and the ingredients are also farm grown and made from wheat. With no harmful ingredients typically found in clay litter, it is a no-worries kind of cat litter. The natural wheat enzymes neutralize odor on contact, and wheat starches clump firmly for easy scooping. Also it’s 100% biodegradable.

The Good

  • Flush-able
  • Does a good job of hiding odors
  • Minimal Dust

The Bad

  • Some tracking
  • Clumps are not firm
  • More pricey than other litters

Cat’s Pride Litter

Cat’s Pride Lightweight Scoopable is a flushable clumping cat litter that instantly absorbs odors and provides a fresh, clean scent. And it’s up to 50% lighter! New lighter density formula with better absorption. Scoopable uses the superior absorbing clays, absorbs moisture and tough odors on contact for a fresh litter box. This litter contains no sodium bentonite which has been rumored to clog plumbing systems. Cat’s pride uses the superior absorbing clays that absorb moisture and tough odors on contact for a fresh litter box. This formula allows litter to clump hard enough to easily scoop, but still disperse in water when flushed.

The Good

  • Great odor control
  • Firm clumping
  • Inexpensive

The Bad

  • May not mask smells well
  • Tracks on floor
  • Maybe dusty

All Natural Clumping Shaved Pine Organic Cat Litter

This natural litter is made out of finely shredded pine wood. It is treated with heat to increase absorbency and reduce dust and allergens. The clumping property presents itself differently from that of clay litter. In clay litter, the clumping starts from the top and forms hard, flat, uneven crumbs. These maybe easy to scoop out but do nothing to control odor or make the surface of the litter box look inviting. This Litter is made completely from USA sourced pine and is free of chemicals, fragrance & dust. Dual action odor control keeps urine and ammonia neutralized and soft clumping makes for simple clean up.

The Good

  • Good odor control
  • Flushable
  • Low dust & tracking

The Bad

  • Very lightweight, may track easily
  • Some cats find it tasty enough to eat
  • Expensive

Fresh Step Ultra

Fresh Step Lightweight Multi-Cat Unscented clumping cat litter is powerful for even the busiest litter boxes. The litter contains carbon to eliminate and trap odors, around the clock. The activated carbon traps and eliminates odors from urine and feces. The high quality, clumping clay quickly absorbs liquids and traps odors, forming tight clumps leaving virtually no stinky crumbles after scooping, making cleaning fast and easy. The lightweight clay makes a 15.4 lb. bag delivers the same number of uses as a 22 lb. bag, while remaining easier to lift, carry and pour. To refresh and maintain your kitty litter box, every time you scoop just add more Fresh Step unscented cat litter.

The Good

  • Good odor control
  • Lightweight formula
  • No strong perfume smell

The Bad

  • Very lightweight, may track easily
  • Clumps are not solid
  • Dusty


There are a lot of cat litters available on the market today, with many pros and cons. Depending on your budget and kitty’s preferences and needs, you will have to select the product that is best for all.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.