Best Fresh Cat Food Delivery Service

Nutrition Reviews February 29, 2020


Best Fresh Cat Food Delivery Service

This page contains affiliate links. We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post through our independently chosen links, which earn us a commission. Learn More

Best Fresh Cat Food Service

Like humans, cats love food that is made fresh. Making fresh food at home is ideal but there isn’t always time for that. This is where fresh delivery cat food services come in handy. But which one is best for your cat and budget?

To get an idea of how fresh cat food services compare, we ordered, researched and tested the popular brands in this article. We will walk you through each companies sign up process, pricing, meal options, shipping, and the number of recipes they offer.

Keep reading to learn everything about these various delivery services, and if they really make your life easier and your cat healthier, without breaking the bank.

Quick Summary:

Our top pick for fresh cat service, goes to Smalls. Pricing is reasonable and they offer extra items like premium cat treats. They also offer more delivery choices and have a user friendly website.

Get 25% OFF Your First Order

How We Tested

  • We purchased service from the 3 fresh cat food services mentioned in this article
  • We spent several weeks testing each cat food service and their recipes
  • We did not receive these products in exchange for a favorable review, they were purchased with our own money

Quick Look At Our Picks for Best Fresh Cat Food Service:

  1. Smalls
  2. Nom Nom
  3. Freshpet

How We Chose The Best Fresh Cat Food Service

  • Nutritionally Complete – Cat food sold in the U.S. is regulated by the Food & Drug Administration (FDA) and the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO). Cat food manufacturers are required to properly label their products, and meet or exceed AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles or follow AAFCO procedures. This also applies to fresh cat food manufacturers.
  • Ordering Process – Setting up an online profile for your cat should not be rocket science. However it should allow for customization based on health issues, weight, breed and/or age. Being able to customize your cats meal plan and select the recipes based on a short question and answer form means less headaches in the long run.
  • Variety of Recipes – Some cats are picky eaters or can not eat certain recipes. Having the choice to change recipes or serving size is a bonus. The more recipes available means a cat food service makes it on our list.
  • Packaging – This is a big deal when your cat is meowing dinner demands. Having to fumble and pull on a food package is not only frustrating but it can be very messy when trying to serve. Also, the box the fresh cat food arrives in, and how cold it is is important, as well as how easy it it to unpack.
  • Price – Most fresh cat food delivery services are pricey and some more than others. We took this in account as well as the amount of meals each provides for the cost. The larger your cat is, the bigger the bill.
  • Flexibility of Delivery – Being able to decide when you want your cat food delivered or how much of it, is part of the convenience of the service. Companies that allow you to pause, cancel or change delivery service is something we definitely considered.
  • Grain free recipes
  • Flexible price plans
  • Sourced from US suppliers
Get 25% Off Your First Order →
  • Pre-portioned sealed meals
  • Fresh to order every week
  • No fillers, grains or artificial flavors
Get 50% Off Your First Order →
  • Recipes for cats with special diets
  • Available in local stores
  • No subscription needed

Advantages of Fresh Cat Food Service

Fresh cat food delivery services are more expensive than grabbing a bag of dry kibble but, there are so many reasons to try it. Cat owners who have made the switch to fresh food claim better health and well-being as well as:

  • Longer life
  • Shiny coat
  • Better hydration
  • More energy
  • Improved immune system
  • Fewer vet visits
  • Less waste

Besides the health benefits, giving your kitty fresh food is personalized and made to order. This means serving sizes are already pre-portioned meals for your cats size and needs.

Fresh food also means less ingredients and no artificial flavors or dyes. If your cat means that much to you then feeding him human grade food makes sense.

Also the convenience and flexibility of choosing meals, delivery days and pausing and/or cancelling meals, makes last minute runs to the store for cat food a thing of the past.

Some fresh food delivery services allow you to stock up for vacation or have food delivered to another location.

Disadvantages of Fresh Cat Food Service

  • Cost- Fresh cat food that is made to order, is not cheap. It is a bit more pricey than the kibble you maybe giving your cat currently, but again, much healthier. We will look more closely at the costs below.
  • Refrigerator Storage– Fresh cat food must be refrigerated or frozen, meaning it will be taking up space in your fridge. Most fresh cat food services state the food can be stored up to 2 weeks in the fridge, but any longer will need to be taking up space in your freezer. This can also make travelling with fresh food difficult.
  • Transitioning your cat to new food – When going from kibble to fresh food, it can be a slow process. It may take up to two weeks to transition to fresh cat food by mixing it with kibble while reducing the amount of kibble. Some cats may take longer because of texture, sensitivity or may not like the recipe. This is where a fresh food service with several recipes can come in handy.

Best Fresh Cat Foods Reviewed

#1 Smalls Cat Food

Available Recipes:

  • Turkey Recipe
  • Beef Recipe
  • Chicken Recipe

The Good

  • The meat and produce are sourced from US suppliers
  • Grain free recipes
  • Plans for every budget
  • Free shipping

The Bad

  • The food must be refrigerated
  • Website is hard to navigate
  • Food packaged in large portions

Location: Chicago, Illinois


Matt Michaelson and Calvin Bohn created a simple and wholesome cat food in their East Village apartment in New York.

They wanted a basic, fresh food with whole ingredients to become their simple recipes for cats. They outcome was Smalls food for cats that is prepared with 100% human grade ingredients.

Smalls wet food recipes were developed with the help of Susan Lauten, Phd, who owns a Pet Nutrition Consulting firm. All of the ingredients are human grade, and meat and produce are sourced from US suppliers. All Smalls foods meet AAFCO standards.


The price of Smalls depends on your cat’s needs, the recipes you choose, and your delivery schedule. With this in mind you will be paying about $2.00 to $3.89 per day per cat depending on the plan you choose and not entirely on cat size.

Their goal is to provide cats with a meal plan that is good for both nutrition and affordability. Smalls offers plenty of options to customize your cat’s meal plan to keep you on budget.

Delivery Options

To sign up with Smalls, you will need to create a profile for your cat with the ability to add up to 5 cat profiles. You will be asked to provide each cats current age, health goal, current food type and recipe selection. You also have flexibility on your budget and what you are willing to pay.

Next you will be provided with a recommended meal plan for your cat. You are able to customize your plan if you don’t agree with their selection.

Depending on the plan you choose, you will be given a delivery schedule which is usually every 4 weeks. Your first box will be a taste sampler, if you chose more than one type of food or recipe. You can then change your cats preferences before your next delivery.

Each pack of food you receive is about three days worth of food, so you will want to start defrosting a pack for your cat once your box arrives. You can skip, pause or cancel orders for the month through your account when needed, as well.

Smalls also includes bonus gifts like bone broth or bonito flakes which can be added to food to entice picky cats.


Smalls offers premium-quality recipes right here in the USA. Not only are their products made with fresh ingredients, they are prepared the same day they are purchased and frozen at the peak of freshness.

Smalls currently offers only three different recipes that include protein sources from beef, turkey and chicken. They also provide customers with many meal plan options for those who are on a tight budget but want the best for their cat.

#2 Nom Nom Cat Food

Available Recipes:

  • Chicken Cuisine
  • Fish Feast

The Good

  • Free Shipping
  • Pre-portioned servings
  • Veterinary nutritionist designs meals
  • Offers cat treat options

The Bad

  • Comparatively on the pricey side
  • Must be refrigerated
  • Packets can be difficult to open

Location: Facilities in San Francisco, California and Nashville, Tennessee


Nom Nom’s meals are made with restaurant-quality ingredients, no artificial preservatives or fillers and portions are optimized to provide your cat with the ideal balance for his age, weight, activity level, breed, as well as any known health issues.

The recipes were developed by the company’s Chief Nutrition Officer, board-certified veterinary nutritionist. The unprocessed meals are made in small batches and with whole foods, to retain more nutrients and exceeds AAFCO standards for cat food formulation for all life stages.

Nom Nom asks you to create a profile for your cat and provide their sex, breed, age, weight, body condition, and your meal preference.


The cost ultimately depends on the weight of your cat which is determine in the profile. Basically meals are portioned based on how much food your cat needs and the bigger the cat the more the cost.

Here is an estimate of cost based on a cats weight:

  • 2 – 7 pounds – $14- $26 weekly or $2 -$3.75 a day
  • 8 – 9 pounds – $18-$30 weekly or $2.60 -$4.30 a day
  • 10 – 13 pounds – $23 -$34 weekly or $3.20-$4.90 a day
  • 14 – 20 pounds – $26- 38 weekly or $3.80 – $5.50 a day

Delivery Options

The weekly deliveries come with a shipment of 14 meal packs (two meals per day), bi-weekly deliveries come with 28 meals, and monthly deliveries come with 56 meals. The more food you order at a time the bigger the discount. If you have multiple cats, Nom Nom offers discounts for multi-pet families. 

Managing your account is easy and you are able to pause/skip up up to four future deliveries if needed.

When your Nom Nom delivery arrives you will find all meal packages neatly organized with rubber bands inside of the box and chilled with dry ice. Your first order will contain a bonus like jerky treats and a booklet on transitioning your dogs food.

If you need to cancel your subscription you will need to contact customer service via email or by phone. You are also able to request extra meals for travel or even have meals delivered to a different address.


Your Nom Nom subscription will be determined ultimately by the weight of your cat, which is all calculated when you create your cat’s profile.

Nom Nom provides 2 meal choices for cats which include chicken and fish recipes. You are able to receive both recipes in your order of change recipes if your cat prefers one over the other.

#3 Freshpet Cat Food

Available Recipes:

  • Freshpet Select
  • Vital
  • Natures Fresh

The Good

  • No subscription needed
  • Available in local retailers
  • Recipe choices for cats with allergies, health problems and food sensitivities

The Bad

  • Some packaging is hard to open
  • Questionable ingredients in some recipes
  • Not all recipes available in stores

Location: Bethlehem, Pennsylvania


Freshpet is the first in the fresh cat food category to be distributed across North America and is available in over 20,000 stores in Canada, the United Kingdom, and the Netherlands as well. Buying in store is the easiest way to get your hands on Fresh Pet foods but if it is not available in your area, there are other options.

Fresh Pet also has a website with several options for ordering your cat’s food and having it delivered to your doorstep.

Freshpet believes in the integrity of their food by vowing to never use meat meals, powders, preservatives, or additives and meets AAFCO standards. Unlike traditional shelf-stable pet foods, Freshpet ingredients are cooked only once at lower temperatures.

In addition, the food does not contain any processed meat meals or by-products, and is made in small batches to preserve the natural goodness of the ingredients.


The cost of Freshpet will depend on many things like your cat’s size but also the product type and recipe. Therefore, there is no average price for your cat by weight alone.

Here is an estimate of what you may pay based on your cat’s size and recipe choice:

  • 5-9 pounds – $5 – $11 weekly or $.70 – $1.60 a day
  • 10-15 pounds – $8 – $20 weekly or $1.15 – $2.85 a day

Delivery Options

Freshpet has a website with several options for ordering your cat’s food and having it delivered to your doorstep. You can choose to order from their suggested online retailers like Amazon Fresh and Prime or select the “find near me” button. What makes them different is their products are also available in retail stores.

You can enter your zip code on the website and a list of local retailers will pop up showing where you can buy Freshpet cat food.

If you choose to use the website, there is a handy tool called product selector. This questionnaire will take you through a series of questions about your cat, asking for name, sex, weight, energy level and dietary needs. You can then select proteins your kitty prefers, like fish and what ingredients you prefer he doesn’t eat, like grains. After answering a few more questions about shopping and meal prepping, you will be given suggestions on what Fresh Pet recipes will work best for your cat and where you can buy them.


What makes them different is Freshpet offers a selection of refrigerated cat foods at your local retailer. You can choose to use the website, and the handy tool called “product selector” to assist you in recipe choices. This questionnaire will take you through a series of questions to help you choose the best product line and flavor for your cat.

Freshpet believes in the integrity of their food by vowing to never use meat meals, powders, preservatives, or additives. Unlike traditional shelf-stable pet foods, Freshpet ingredients are cooked only once at lower temperatures and combines meats with fruits and vegetables to make fresh, natural cat food.

Fresh Cat Food Cost Comparison

Nom Nom7 to 20 Pounds$ 104.00 to $ 152.00
Smalls5 to 20 Pounds$ 60.00 to $ 117.00
Freshpet5 to 15 Pounds$ 20.00 to $ 80.00

Bottom Line

All of the above mentioned fresh cat food delivery services offer healthy options but each one has their pros and cons. Each offers free shipping when purchased directly through them, and most offer gluten/grain free meals and meet AAFCO standards.

If we had to pick one fresh cat food service, it would be Nom Nom. They offer 3 different shipping options an two quality recipes for your cat. Their website is easy to navigate an make changes or pause shipments when needed.

Smalls is also great if you are on a tight budget but want the best for your cat. They also include bonus items in your shipments to assist with picky eaters.

Pet Plate maybe preferable for cat owners who prefer to shop in-store. It is fast an easy to pick it up while doing other shopping and they offer many recipes and flavors.

Related Articles

Amy is the founder of Cat Mania and a life long cat lover. She also writes for various other pet related websites. She is passionate about helping pet parents create a healthy and happy lifestyle for their fur-babies.
  1. Sad Fresh Cat Food Customer

    We have been using NomNom and Smalls for the past year. I can say we were really excited at first but the customer service for both companies essentially killed our customer relationship. With Smalls, I wanted to decrease our order and also pause our order because cats being cats, they were no longer eating the food. I was still planning on ordering more dry for a friend but when it came to corresponding with the Smalls company, they burned the bridge by saying they essentially didn’t believe my cats were not eating the food because I had ordered so much. I didn’t even understand why that was part of the conversation but, we are no longer customers, sadly. For NomNom, their communication was also the reason we are no longer customers - also, because they changed their offering to chicken only while they ‘reformulate’ (whatever that means) their other selections, we responded we didn’t want any chicken. Instead of pausing our account, they just cancelled it. No effort to try to keep us as over $200 a month customers in any way - they just cancelled us. I only found out when I went to actually add some dog food to my order. So, in essence, looks like there is room for a fresh cat food company to swoop in because if they have a good product AND good customer relation skills - they could be profitable.

    • Cat Mania

      I am sorry this happened to you and am disappointed that customer service for both of these fresh cat food companies failed you. The good news is many fresh cat food companies are popping up which gives you a chance to give your kitties some variety. Maybe consider Raised Right Cat Food or Fresh Pet which can be found in big box retail stores.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.